Home › Locations › Pennsylvania › Lancaster
Can a Business Plan Tell Me If a Lancaster Business Idea Will Be Profitable?
Lancaster County has more farms than any other county in Pennsylvania, and many of those families are weighing whether to turn milk into cheese or ice cream on the farm. Business plan writer Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, helps Lancaster County dairy farms test a new product line on paper before the equipment is ordered.
- 1,000+clients
- $100M+in fundable projects
- 14+years
Yes, With Limits
How Does a Business Plan Predict Profit?
The Traditional Answer
A business plan predicts profitability by projecting revenue and subtracting all projected costs over a set period, usually three to five years. The projections rest on stated assumptions about price, sales volume, cost of production and overhead. The plan is only as reliable as those assumptions, so each should be researched and tested.
Doctor Owl in Plain English
A plan cannot promise profit. It can show you what has to be true for the idea to pay, and then you go check whether it is.
How this guide worksRead the standard answer, then Doctor Owl’s shorter one, then watch a careful tortoise decide whether to buy a kiln in a scene from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. The sections after that compare selling raw with selling finished, walk through a profit test and list who in Lancaster County can help.
Thinking About On Farm Processing? Run It on Paper
Use as much or as little of Dr. Paul’s time as the decision needs. See plan pricing.
Business Consulting
Spend an hour with Dr. Paul testing whether the price lift beats the added cost.
See consulting optionsBusiness Plan Writing
A feasibility plan with projections for the new product line.
How Dr. Paul writes plansBusiness Plan Templates
Rough out the numbers yourself with a food production template.
Browse templatesVisitors leaving without buying? Learn how Lancaster owners sell without feeling pushy.
The Lancaster Opportunity
Why Do Lancaster County Farms Look at On Farm Processing?
Milk sells at a price the farm does not set. Cheese sells at a price the farm does.
Lancaster County counted 4,680 farms in the last federal farm census, and an earlier census ranked it ahead of every other county in the state. Many are small dairies run by a single family.
A small dairy has little say over what it is paid for milk. That is why so many families look at making something from it. Cheese, yogurt and ice cream carry the farm’s own name and the farm’s own price.
The state has backed the idea. Its Dairy Investment Program has funded value added processing, and Lancaster County farms that supply a cheese brand have been tied to those grants.
The catch is cost. A processing room needs vats, coolers, packaging and inspections. Someone has to make the product, and someone has to sell it. Those are new jobs on a farm that already has plenty.
Some farms come out well ahead. Others find the higher price is eaten by the higher cost. The time to learn which kind you are is before you buy the vat.
Two Paths
Is Selling Raw Product or Finished Goods the Better Bet?
Finished goods score higher on price. They also score higher on everything else.
The question is never whether the price goes up. It is whether the price goes up by more than the cost, the labor and the risk combined.
The Test
How Does a Business Plan Test Profit Before You Buy Equipment?
It walks the idea through four checks, in order.
What will people pay?
Real prices from stores, markets and farms selling a similar product near you.
How much can you sell?
A cautious count of outlets and customers, not a hopeful one.
What does it cost to make?
Equipment, ingredients, packaging, labor, inspections and the milk itself, valued at what you could have sold it for.
How long until it pays back?
Year by year, when the new line covers its own costs and returns the money you put in.
A profitability test puts price, volume and cost together and shows whether the new product pays, and when. Dr. Paul Borosky writes it with your farm’s own numbers before any equipment is bought.
Doctor Owl Teaches
What Made Thelma Finally Spend on the New Kiln?
Thelma the Tortoise makes clay pots in the desert and has never spent a coin she did not have to. Cal the Camel runs the trading post next door.
Thelma sold plain clay pots. They brought a fair price and she kept every coin of it. A traveler told her glazed pots sold for double.
Glazing meant another kiln, and a kiln meant spending. Thelma did not walk next door to ask Cal about it. She wrote him a note. What do glazed bowls fetch at your post? What do glazed jars fetch?
Cal wrote back by sundown. Thelma laid his prices next to her own list. Kiln. Glaze. Extra fuel. The days each batch would take. The pieces that crack when fired again.
She worked it slowly, as she did everything. Glazed bowls lost money. Too many cracked, and the price was only a little better. Glazed water jars were another story. Hardly any cracked, and Cal could sell all she made.
So Thelma opened her coin box at last. She bought a small kiln, sized for jars, and left the bowls plain.
The lesson: A higher price is not the same as a profit. Test each product before you pay for the equipment. Read more in Strategy for Small Businesses.
What Farms Make
Which Lancaster County Farm Products Sell Best Once Processed?
There is no ranking to point to. These are the products farms most often consider, with what to weigh for each.
Cheese
Keeps well and travels well. Needs aging space and patience before the opening sale.
Ice cream
Draws visitors to the farm. Sales lean hard on the warm months.
Yogurt and bottled milk
Repeat buyers every week. A short shelf life means delivery has to be reliable.
Butter and cheese curds
Simpler to make. Margins are thinner, so volume matters.
Baked goods and jams from farm crops
Low equipment cost. Easy for neighbors to copy.
The business plan templates include food production models that can serve as a starting draft.
Local Help
Which Lancaster Programs Help Farms Test a New Product?
Talk to these before you price equipment.
Center for Dairy Excellence
Keeps a list of consultants for dairy farms entering value added products and runs grant programs for Pennsylvania dairies.
2301 North Cameron Street, Harrisburg, PA 17110
Penn State Extension
Publishes a list of shared commercial kitchens, including in Lancaster, where a farm can make test batches before building its own room.
Kutztown University Small Business Development Center
Serves Lancaster County and has consulted with many Pennsylvania food producers.
Quick Answers
How Long Should a Farm Product Line Take to Turn a Profit?
How long before a new farm product turns a profit?
Can I test the product before I build anything?
Should the plan count my family’s labor as a cost?
What if the plan says the idea will not pay?

About Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
Dr. Paul has tested new business ideas on paper for more than 1,000 owners, and some of those plans ended with a clear no. Lancaster County families meet with him over the phone or on screen. His Organize-Plan-Grow™ method starts by organizing what the farm already earns, so the new line is judged against real numbers.
Outside of plan writing, Dr. Paul works as a business consultant and author. See who he is, and pick up a book from his Amazon store.
Other Pennsylvania topics are on the Pennsylvania business plan writer page, and the locations page has the full list of cities.