Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
Business Consultant & Author
Should a Small Business Build or Buy Its Software and Tools?
It Felt Free Because It Was Your Own Time.
The most capable owners Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, works with have a costly habit. They can build almost anything, so they do: a custom spreadsheet, a homemade website, an inventory system that only they understand. It feels cheaper than buying. It almost never is, because the build costs hours they would have spent on paying work. Here is how to decide.
Last Updated: 11/15/2026 · Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
The Definition
What Is a Build or Buy Decision?
Short Answer
Build or buy means choosing between making a tool yourself, whether that is a system, a spreadsheet, a website, or a piece of gear, and purchasing one that exists. Write down the jobs it must do, strike out every job a ready-made product already handles, and see what remains. Purchase the common part. Make only what is unique to how you earn.
True cost to build = parts + (your hours × what those hours earn on paying work)
Doctor Owl, in Plain English
“Build what makes you different. Buy what makes you the same as everyone else.”
How This Guide Works
Need the test? The Short Answer and the four steps give it to you. Want to see the trap? Follow Alton, an ant from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series who can fix anything and spends eleven days building his own register. His story runs in gold notes, and the cost math has its own section.
Want a Straight Answer on What to Build and What to Buy?
Talk it through with Dr. Paul, plan the spend, or learn the test first. Start with the tool you are building right now.
Business Consulting
Building something you could buy? Dr. Paul helps you price your hours and decide what is worth making.
See consulting options →Business Plan Writing
Dr. Paul writes plans that show equipment and software spending a lender can follow.
Start your plan →Business Plan Templates
FeaturedA ready-made Word plan and Excel model, so you don’t build the financial model yourself.
Browse templates →Small Business Education
Free lessons and Fabled Forest books on tools, technology, and owner time.
Start learning →From Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest
Meet Alton: An Ant Who Can Build a Better One
Alton can repair anything with a gear in it. In Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series, he runs a repair shop on the square with his partner, Pippa, whose name went up on the sign last summer. When the forest’s new registers arrive from the coast, Alton decides he can build a better one.
On day eleven he takes it apart for the fourth time and lays every piece out in rows. Meanwhile eighteen repair tickets hang on the hook behind him, and the clocks in the window haven’t been wound since Thursday. Doctor Owl brings in the Lone Oak’s kitchen clock. Pippa writes ticket number nineteen.
Why It Matters
Why Do Capable Owners Build Tools They Should Buy?
Because they can, and because it feels free. The parts are cheap and the time is their own. But owner time is the most expensive resource in a small business. Every hour spent building a box you could have bought is an hour taken from the work customers pay for.
A homemade tool also needs a maintainer, and that is usually the person who built it. When it breaks, only one person can fix it. A build or buy decision puts both costs on paper before the first hour goes in.
Signs you have this problem:
- You are building a tool while paying work waits.
- Only you understand the spreadsheet or system the business runs on.
- You compare the price of parts to the price of a product and stop there.
- Your tool has features nobody asked for.
- A standard product does 90 percent of what you need, and you are building the other 10 from scratch.
- Someone close to you keeps asking how many hours it has taken.
In the Fabled Forest
Alton was proud of the savings. The coast register cost forty coins and his parts had cost thirty. Pippa, at the counter, didn’t argue. She asked one short thing: “And the sixty hours?”
The Test
How Do You Tell What to Build From What to Buy?
- Write what the tool must do. What, not how. Plain sentences.
- Cross out what standard products already do well. Adding, printing, storing, reporting: someone has solved it.
- Look at what’s left. Is it truly specific to how you make money, or just a preference?
- Price your hours honestly. At what they would earn on paying work, not zero.
- Buy the standard, build only the rest. If anything is left at all.
In the Fabled Forest
Pippa made Alton write his list on the back of a repair ticket: what it had to do, not how. Fourteen lines. Then he walked across the square to look at the optician’s coast register and crossed off every line it already did. Thirteen crosses. The one line left was counting the parts used on each job. “That’s mine,” he said. “It’s how we price.”
When Building Wins
When Does It Make Sense to Build Your Own Tool?
When the leftover list is real. If the part you can’t buy is the reason customers choose you, like a pricing method, a scheduling rule, or a service nobody else offers, that part may be worth building. Even then, build it on top of a standard tool, not instead of one.
Building also makes sense when no product exists and you have checked, not assumed. The test is the same either way: what does it cost in hours, and who keeps it running? A decision like this belongs on your technology roadmap, not on a slow afternoon.
In the Fabled Forest
Alton ordered the coast register that afternoon. It worked the day it arrived. The next day he built the one thing that was his: a matchbox-sized brass counter that ticks over every time a part comes out of a drawer. It took four hours. Then he started on the hook.
The Numbers
What Does a Homemade Tool Really Cost?
Here is Alton’s register, priced the honest way. Do the same for the tool you are building.
| Cost item | Build it | Buy it |
|---|---|---|
| Parts or purchase price | $30 | $40 |
| Owner hours | 60 | 2 (setup) |
| Owner hours at $50 on paying work | $3,000 | $100 |
| True cost | $3,030 | $140 |
Illustration. The book counts coins: 30 for parts, 40 for the coast register, and 60 hours. The dollar figures are examples.
Step 1: Count the parts. Building saved $10 on parts. That is the number most owners stop at.
Step 2: Count the hours. 60 hours × $50 an hour of repair work = $3,000 of paying work that waited or walked to a competitor.
Step 3: Compare. $3,030 to build versus $140 to buy and set up. Building cost about 21 times more, and it still needs a maintainer.
Illustrative numbers. Hours and parts come from the book; the hourly value is an example.
Step by Step
How Do You Make a Build or Buy Decision?
Four steps, done before the first part is ordered.
Write down everything the tool needs to do.
Describe the result, not the method. Keep it to plain sentences.
Cross out what standard products already do.
Look at two or three real products before you decide nothing fits.
Price your own hours honestly.
Use what those hours would earn on paying work. Some of that work waits for you. Some of it walks to a competitor.
Buy the standard, build only what’s yours.
If anything survives the cross-outs, build only that, ideally on top of what you bought. The common mistake is pricing the materials and forgetting the hours.
In the Fabled Forest
Pippa pinned the four lines over the workbench at ant height, where Alton would see them every time he reached for his magnifying glass.
Alton’s Full Story
What Happened to the Fourteen Features?
The book has all eleven days, the cam Alton was so proud of, the list Pippa made him write, and what he finally did with his skill once the hook was empty.
Technology and AI for Small Businesses covers buying, building, and using tools, one owner at a time, without naming a single real product.
A Business Consultant’s View
What Do Business Consultants See When Owners Build Their Own Tools?
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA · Business Consultant
Dr. Paul sees this most with owners who are good with their hands or good with spreadsheets. They build a custom system because the store-bought one seems wrong in a few small ways. A year later the business runs on something only the owner can fix, and the owner is still the bottleneck. Dr. Paul has owners price their own hours at what they bill customers. The answer usually ends the debate. It also fits the Plan step of his Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy: decide where your hours go on purpose, and spend them where only you can earn.
FAQ
What Else Do Owners Ask About Building or Buying?
How do you decide whether to build or buy software?
Is it cheaper to build my own business tools?
What is the biggest mistake in build or buy decisions?
Keep Going
Keep Choosing Carefully
This is foundation 6 of twenty. Look up any term in the technology and AI glossary.
How to Get Employees to Use New Technology
One tool at a time, with training and a date to decide.
What Is Total Cost of Ownership?
The full price of whatever you buy.
What Is Opportunity Cost?
What your hours could have earned instead (Book 6 guide).
What Is Process Mapping?
Know the job before you build or buy anything.
Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, business consultant and author of books on Amazon. Building a tool you could buy? Talk it through with Dr. Paul.
This page is for general education. It is not legal, security, or other professional advice. No real products are named or endorsed, the numbers are illustrations, and the Fabled Forest is invented.