Home › How to Start a Business › Choosing a Business Structure
How to Choose a Business Structure: LLC, S Corp, or Sole Proprietor?
LLC, S corp, or sole proprietor? Most owners pick in five minutes, then the first tax bill or a lawsuit shows them what it meant. Business plan writer Dr. Paul Borosky has set up the structure in 1,000+ plans. Here's how to pick yours on purpose.
- 1,000+clients
- $100M+in fundable projects
- 14+years
Structure Picked? Put It in a Plan Lenders Trust.
Your structure is the first thing a lender reads in the company description. Dr. Paul writes the plan around it. See plan pricing.
Business Consulting
Not sure the S corp math works yet? Talk through structure, pay and taxes before you file.
Talk to a consultantBusiness Plan Writing
A full plan with the company description, ownership and projections a lender expects.
How Dr. Paul writes plansBusiness Plan Templates
Writing it yourself? Start from an industry template with the sections already laid out.
Browse templatesThe Short Answer
What Is a Business Structure, and Why Does It Matter?
A business structure is the legal form your business takes: sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company (LLC), S corporation or C corporation. It decides who owns the business, how its profit is taxed, and whether the owner’s personal assets can be reached for the business’s debts. You register most structures with your state before you open.
Doctor Owl in Plain English
Your business structure decides two things: how you pay tax and how much of your personal stuff is at risk. A sole proprietorship is simple but puts everything on the line. An LLC protects your personal assets. An S corp can lower self-employment tax once profit is steady. Pick on purpose, then confirm with your CPA and attorney.
How this guide worksDoctor Owl is standing in line at town hall when a new owner tells him she filed “whatever was fastest.” Follow her through the choices, then use the checklist to make your own. Doctor Owl’s full lessons on money and risk are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
The Problem
What Happens When Owners Pick Whatever Is Fastest?
Most new owners choose a structure in five minutes. A friend suggested it. A filing website made it the default. It felt like paperwork, not a decision.
Then reality shows up. The first tax bill is bigger than expected because every dollar of profit got hit with self-employment tax. Or a customer gets hurt, and the owner learns that a sole proprietorship puts the house and savings within reach. Or a lender asks why the business isn’t set up to protect its owner, and who exactly will sign for the loan.
None of these surprises is rare. They come from treating the structure as a form to fill out instead of a decision about money and risk.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Doctor Owl Stop the Young Hedgehog at Town Hall?
Here, a young baker learns her structure is a money decision.
Doctor Owl was third in line at town hall, license renewal form in wing, when the young hedgehog ahead of him turned around.
“Do you know how long this takes?” she asked. “I already filed my bakery stall. Took four minutes. Picked whatever was fastest.”
At the next window, Agnes the Armadillo looked up from her clipboard. She is not a villain. She is a deadline with half-moon spectacles. “Fastest usually means sole owner,” she said. “Then all of the profit is yours. So is all of the tax on it. Due on the date. Never late.”
Lenora the Lynx, waiting with a stack of contracts, tapped the hedgehog’s form with her red pencil. “And this part,” she said. “If a customer slips on your step, they can come after the stall and your house. Let’s read that part again.”
The hedgehog went pale under her quills.
“Well wow,” said Doctor Owl, kindly enough. “Nothing is broken yet. This isn’t a fire. It’s a foundation. Three questions, and you choose on purpose.”
You’ll see those three questions below.
The lesson: the structure you pick in five minutes can cost you for years. Choose it on purpose, then confirm it with a CPA and an attorney.
Compare
Sole Proprietor, LLC, Partnership, S Corp or C Corp: What’s the Difference?
| Structure | Who it fits | Personal protection | How profit is taxed | Paperwork |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sole proprietorship | One owner testing an idea with little risk | None | On your personal return, plus self-employment tax | Lowest |
| General partnership | Two or more owners sharing the work | None, and each partner can be on the hook for the others | On each partner’s personal return | Low, but get a written agreement |
| LLC | Most small businesses with real risk | Yes, when run properly | Like a sole proprietorship or partnership by default | Moderate |
| S corporation (a tax election) | Owners with steady profit above a fair salary | Yes | Salary through payroll; remaining profit avoids self-employment tax | Higher |
| C corporation | Businesses raising money from outside investors | Yes | The business pays its own tax; owners pay again on dividends | Highest |
The LLC is the most common choice for small businesses because it adds protection without much paperwork. The S corporation is not a separate kind of company. It is a tax choice an LLC or corporation can make later.
Risk
Which Business Structure Protects Your Personal Assets?
An LLC or a corporation puts a legal wall between the business and you. If the business is sued or can’t pay a supplier, the business’s assets are at risk, not your house or personal savings. A sole proprietorship and a general partnership have no wall at all.
The wall only holds if you treat the business as separate. Owners weaken it when they mix business and personal money, skip the paperwork their state requires, or sign contracts in their own name. And it does not cover everything. If you personally guarantee a loan or a lease, or you personally cause an injury, your own assets can still be reached.
That is why business insurance still matters after you form an LLC. General liability insurance covers what the structure can’t, and many leases and contracts will ask you to show it.
Dr. Paul’s Insight
Dr. Paul sees owners surprised by one line in their first loan: the personal guarantee. Even with an LLC, the lender usually asks the owner to sign personally. The structure protects you from customers and suppliers. It rarely protects you from your own lender.
Show the Math
How Is Each Business Structure Taxed?
Sole proprietors and default LLCs pay income tax on all profit, plus self-employment tax for Social Security and Medicare. An S corporation pays the owner a reasonable salary through payroll, and profit above that salary avoids self-employment tax. A C corporation pays its own tax, and owners pay again on any dividends.
Example only. Federal self-employment and payroll tax only; income tax, state tax, and costs vary.
A business earns $60,000 in profit.
| Sole proprietor or default LLC | LLC taxed as an S corp | |
|---|---|---|
| Owner salary | none (all profit is self-employment income) | $40,000 reasonable salary |
| Tax base for Social Security and Medicare | $60,000 x 92.35% = $55,410 | $40,000 salary |
| Rate | 15.3% | 15.3% (split between owner and business) |
| Tax | about $8,478 | about $6,120 |
The S corp election saves about $2,358 here. Then subtract the costs: a payroll service, a separate business tax return, and more bookkeeping. At this profit, much of the savings can disappear. At higher profit, it usually grows.
Dr. Paul’s Insight
Dr. Paul tells owners not to chase the S corp election in year one. Wait until profit is steady and clearly above a fair salary, then run the numbers with your CPA. Electing too early can cost more in payroll and tax prep than it saves.
The Fix
How Do You Form an LLC, Step by Step?
- Pick and check your name. Search your state’s business name database. The name usually has to include “LLC” or “Limited Liability Company.”
- Choose a registered agent. Every LLC needs one: a person or company with an address in the state who accepts legal papers for the business. You can serve as your own if you have a physical address there.
- File articles of organization. File online with your Secretary of State or similar office and pay the state fee.
- Write an operating agreement. It sets out who owns what, who decides, and what happens if an owner leaves. Only some states require one. Every LLC with more than one owner needs one.
- Get an EIN from the IRS. It’s free and takes minutes online. Banks, payroll, and many permits ask for it.
- Open a business bank account. Keep every business dollar in it from the first day.
- Mark your calendar. Most states require an annual or biennial report and fee to keep the LLC in good standing.
Cost and Time
How Much Does It Cost to Form an LLC, and How Long Does It Take?
State filing fees for an LLC range from $35 in Montana to $500 in Massachusetts. Many states also charge a yearly or every-other-year report fee, and a few charge much more. California, for example, has an $800 minimum yearly franchise tax.
Filing online is usually the fastest route, often approved within days. Mailed filings can take weeks. The EIN is free and immediate online. Budget, too, for a registered agent service if you won’t serve as your own, and for an attorney or CPA review if your situation is more than simple.
Check your own state’s Secretary of State website for the current fee and timeline before you file. Fees change.
Your Business Plan
How Does a Business Plan Writer Show Your Structure to a Lender?
Your structure belongs in the company description: the legal name, the structure, the owners and their shares, and the state where you filed. Lenders read it to know who they’re lending to, who signs the personal guarantee, and what happens if an owner leaves.
A business plan writer makes sure the structure matches the rest of the plan. If you’ve elected S corp status, the projections show an owner salary through payroll, not just owner draws. If there are partners, the plan shows who owns what and who manages what. If you’re raising money from investors, the plan explains how ownership changes after they invest.
Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy puts the structure in the Organize stage, before a single page of the plan gets written. See how to write the company description.
Free Help
Where Can You Get Free Help Choosing a Business Structure?
- Your state’s Secretary of State website. Fees, forms, name searches, and annual report rules for your state.
- Small Business Development Centers (SBDCs). The SBA funds 63 lead centers with hundreds of local offices. Advisors walk you through structure, registration, and taxes at no cost.
- SCORE. More than 9,000 volunteer mentors, many of them retired owners and professionals, offer free one-on-one sessions in person or online.
- Women’s Business Centers and Veterans Business Outreach Centers. Free counseling for women and veteran owners.
- A CPA and an attorney. Not free, but often worth one meeting before you file, especially with partners or an S corp election in mind.
Quick Answers
Questions About Choosing a Structure
What is the best business structure for a small business?
Can I change my business structure later?
Does an LLC protect my personal assets completely?
Start a Business, Step 4 of 10
Keep Going
← Step 3: Financial ProjectionsBack to How to Start a BusinessStep 5: How to Fund a Small Business →

Meet Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
Dr. Paul has written business plans for 1,000+ owners across 14+ years, and every one starts with the company description: who owns what, and how. His books are on his Amazon author page.
Picked your structure? Have a business plan writer put it to work in a plan a lender will read.
Confirm your choice with a CPA and an attorney. This page is general education, not legal or tax advice. Fees and rules change; check your state and local offices. The Fabled Forest and its characters are fictional.