Home › Locations › Connecticut › New Haven
Is a Business Plan Required to Open a Second Location in New Haven?
New Haven’s most famous pizzerias are opening new shops across the Northeast, and smaller apizza owners with a line at the door feel the pull. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, works as a business plan writer and helps New Haven restaurant owners plan the people, systems and money behind a second location.
- 1,000+clients
- $100M+in fundable projects
- 14+years
Short Version
Is a Business Plan Needed for a Second Location?
The Traditional Answer
A business plan is strongly recommended before opening a second location and is usually required if the expansion is financed. The plan evaluates the new site, defines the management structure for both locations and projects the combined finances. It also explains how the original location will hold its performance during the expansion.
Doctor Owl in Plain English
Yes. The shop you have works because you are standing in it. The plan answers what happens when you are standing somewhere else.
How this guide worksHere the business side comes before the story. Then a fox, a marten and an otter show what it looks like in a kitchen, in a scene from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. The page explains why second shops strain the original, who runs what, where New Haven restaurants expand and what the plan has to prove.
Line at the Door? Plan Before You Sign Another Lease
Choose how much help you want with the expansion. See plan pricing.
Business Consulting
Review your current shop’s numbers with Dr. Paul to see if it can fund another.
See consulting optionsBusiness Plan Writing
An expansion plan covering the site, the managers and both sets of books.
How Dr. Paul writes plansOne strong performer upsetting the whole team? Read how New Haven owners handle a talented but difficult employee.
The New Haven Problem
Why Do New Haven Pizzerias Struggle When They Open a Second Shop?
A crowd proves people want your food. It does not prove the business can be in two places.
Expansion is in the air on Wooster Street. Sally’s stayed a single shop for most of a century. After a sale to an investment group, it began opening new restaurants in 2021 and has since announced plans for hundreds more. Frank Pepe has grown to 17 locations in seven states.
Those names have something most independent owners lack. They have outside money, a head office and managers whose whole job is opening new stores.
An independent owner has a great pie and a long line. The shop works because the owner is at the oven, tastes the sauce and knows the regulars.
Open another shop and that owner can only be in a single kitchen at a time. The new place gets the attention. The original slips a little each week. Regulars are the ones who notice.
The trouble is rarely the recipe. Nothing was written down, and nobody else was ready to lead.
Who Does What
Who Runs Each Kitchen When a Pizzeria Has Two Locations?
With a single shop, every decision runs through the owner. With more than that, it cannot.
Your plan should name the person in each box and say what they decide without calling you.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Frankie Add His Own Key to Marco’s Ring?
Fast Frankie the Fox runs a pizzeria and never stops moving. Marco the Marten is his steady general manager, and Nell the Otter runs the ovens.
Frankie’s pizzeria had a line down the lane every night. So he found a spot for another oven across the forest. He planned to run both himself.
For a week he tried. He raced between the old shop and the empty new one, talking the whole way. Marco had written the supper schedule. Frankie crossed out names each time he ran through.
Two pies burned. Nell pulled them and started again without a word. Dex gave change for an order nobody had made.
That night Marco took the schedule down, wrote it out fresh and hung it higher than a fox could reach.
Frankie stood and looked up at it. Then he unhooked his own key and added it to Marco’s ring. For a full month he stayed out of the old shop. The line did not get shorter. Only then did he sign for the new oven.
The lesson: Prove the shop you have can run without you before you open the next. Read more in Growth for Small Businesses.
Where They Go
Where Do New Haven Restaurants Open Their Second Location?
The big names have left a trail. It shows the kinds of places a New Haven food brand can travel to.
Fairfield County
Stamford and Fairfield were early stops for a Wooster Street pizzeria as it grew within the state.
The Hartford suburbs
Wethersfield came next, followed by a spot on the Berlin Turnpike in Newington.
Malls and casinos
Newer sites include a regional mall and a casino resort, where the foot traffic is already there.
Greater Boston
Two Wooster Street names now have shops in Massachusetts.
An independent shop usually expands closer to home, where the owner can drive between kitchens in a single shift.
The Fix
What Does a Second Location Business Plan Need to Prove?
A lender, a landlord and your own family will all ask the same four things.
The original can run without you
Written recipes, prep lists and a manager who already makes the daily calls.
The new site fits
Rent, parking, nearby homes and competition, compared with what made the original work.
The money holds up
Build out, opening stock and months of losses at the new shop, paid without starving the old one.
Someone leads each kitchen
A named manager at each address and a clear list of what still comes to you.
A second location plan proves the original shop is ready to run on its own and the new shop can pay for itself. Dr. Paul Borosky writes it from your current sales, your lease options and your team.
Local Help
Which New Haven Programs Help Restaurant Owners Grow?
All three offer advice at no charge.
Small Business Resource Center, City of New Haven
The city’s office for owners who want to start, grow or find funding.
New Haven SCORE
Volunteer mentors who offer private sessions and workshops.
Gateway Community College Small Business Center, 20 Church Street, New Haven, CT 06510
Connecticut Small Business Development Center
Full time advisors for owners in every industry and at every stage.
Quick Answers
Should a Second Pizzeria Copy the First Menu Exactly?
Should the new shop have the same menu?
How do I know my current shop is ready?
How far away should the new shop be?
How long until a new location pays for itself?

About Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
Of the 1,000 plus owners on Dr. Paul’s client list, many came to him when they were ready to add a location. He works with New Haven owners by phone and video. His Organize-Plan-Grow™ method starts by getting the current shop organized, which is the step most expansions skip.
Dr. Paul is also a business consultant and the author of a small business book series. Meet Dr. Paul, or browse his books on his Amazon author page.
For anything statewide, start at the Connecticut business plan writer page. The locations page lists every other city.