What Does Investing in a Downturn Mean?

Short Answer

Investing in a downturn means buying something your business truly needs during a weak economy, when prices fall and competitors sit still. It makes sense only if three tests pass: your cash reserve still covers several months of costs after the purchase, the purchase earns back its cost even on cautious numbers such as half your expected sales, and it sits close to what your business already does well.

Buy in a downturn only if: reserve still covers months + payback on half the sales + it’s your core

Doctor Owl, in Plain English

“What would you need to see, to say yes?”

How This Guide Works

Need the three tests? The Short Answer and the four steps lay them out. Want the story? Follow Thelma, a tortoise from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series who has saved for eleven years and finds a kiln for sale at a third of its old price. Her story runs in gold notes, and the payback math has its own section.

Thinking About a Big Purchase in a Hard Year?

Test the purchase with Dr. Paul, model the payback, or learn the three tests first. Start with your reserve.

Business Plan Writing

Buying equipment or a business? Dr. Paul writes the plan that shows lenders the payback.

Start your plan →

Business Plan Templates

A Word plan and Excel model to test payback on careful numbers.

Browse templates →

Small Business Education

Free lessons and Fabled Forest books on growth, reserves, and lasting through hard years.

Start learning →

Meet Thelma: A Tortoise With Coins in a Jar

Thelma makes pots in the desert. In Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series, she has kept four hundred coins in a jar under her wheel for eleven years, and spent none of them on anything but clay.

Her kiln fires once a week, and she has more orders than pots. Now, in the hard winter, the potter down the road is moving away and selling her kiln for a hundred coins, a third of its price two years ago. Everyone says not to spend in a bad winter. Thelma writes to Doctor Owl to ask if this is the time.

Why Can a Recession Be a Good Time to Buy?

Because prices drop and sellers get motivated when buyers disappear. Equipment, leases, and even competitors can be had for far less. The owners who planned and saved get options that disappear once the economy recovers.

But a bargain you can’t afford, or don’t need, is still a mistake. Investing in a downturn works only with a floor under you. It’s the Grow step of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, taken carefully.

Signs a downturn purchase might make sense:

  • You have a reserve that would survive the purchase.
  • You already have more demand than capacity.
  • The item is something your business uses every day.
  • The price is well below what it cost a year or two ago.
  • It would pay back even if sales fell by half.
  • You’re not buying it just because it’s cheap.

In the Fabled Forest

Doctor Owl didn’t tell Thelma yes or no. He sent down a single question on the next wagon: what would you need to see, to say yes? Her answer took several days to write, because she thought all the way to the bottom.

How Do You Decide Whether to Invest in a Recession?

  • Reserve test. After you spend, does the reserve still cover at least six months of costs?
  • Payback test. Does it earn back its price even if you get only half the sales you expect?
  • Core test. Is it close to what your business already does well, not a sideline?
  • Write the answers down. Numbers, not feelings, for each test.
  • If any test fails, wait. The next bargain will come.

In the Fabled Forest

Thelma’s costs were about thirty coins a month, so six months was a hundred and eighty. Spending a hundred would leave three hundred in the jar. On half the orders, the kiln paid back in about five months. And it was pots, which was what she did.

What Purchases Should You Avoid in a Downturn?

Anything outside your core, however cheap. A downturn tempts owners to buy what’s on sale rather than what they’d use: a second location in the wrong place, a side business, equipment for work they don’t do. If you wouldn’t know what to do with it, it isn’t a bargain.

And don’t spend the reserve that protects you. See how much cash reserve to keep before you count anything as spare.

In the Fabled Forest

Thelma pointed out she’d watched a friend buy forty hats. She wasn’t going to buy the potter’s donkey, house, or rugs because they were cheap that winter. The kiln was the only thing there she’d know what to do with.

How Do You Run the Three Tests on Real Numbers?

Payback math ahead. Skip it if the steps are enough.

Here are Thelma’s tests, from the book, with dollars added. Run your own purchase through the same table.

TestThelma’s numbersPass?
Reserve before purchase$4,000
Purchase price$1,000 (was $3,000)
Reserve after vs. six months of costs$3,000 vs. $1,800Yes
Payback at half the expected ordersAbout 5 monthsYes
Close to the core?A kiln for a potterYes
DecisionBuy

Figures from the book (400-coin jar, 100-coin kiln, 30 coins a month in costs) at ten dollars a coin.

Step 1: Reserve test. Six months of costs is $1,800. After buying, $3,000 remains. Pass.

Step 2: Payback test. Assume half the orders the second kiln could fill. It still pays back in about five months. Pass.

Step 3: Core test. A second kiln for a potter with more orders than pots. Pass. All three hold, so buy.

Illustrative dollar conversion of the book’s numbers.

How Do You Evaluate a Downturn Purchase Step by Step?

Four steps before you spend in a hard year.

  1. Know your monthly costs.

    Rent, supplies, payroll, and the small things, so you can size six months.

  2. Check the reserve after purchase.

    It should still cover at least six months of costs.

  3. Halve the expected sales.

    Work out payback on cautious numbers, not hopeful ones.

  4. Ask if it’s your core.

    Buy only what you’d use every week. The common mistake is buying because it’s cheap.

In the Fabled Forest

Doctor Owl mailed Thelma her scroll, the first he’d ever sent rather than handed over: reserve still six months? pays back at half the orders? your core? She kept it in the jar, on top of the coins.

What Came Out of the First Firing?

The book has the letter in Thelma’s slow hand, the jar under the wheel, the four days it took to bring the kiln home, and what the post wagon carried that winter.

Survival for Small Businesses covers lasting through the hard years, and using them well.

What Do Business Consultants Advise About Investing in a Recession?

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA · Business Consultant

Dr. Paul sees two mistakes in a downturn. Owners with healthy reserves often refuse to spend anything, even when demand outruns capacity and prices have fallen. Owners without reserves sometimes buy cheap assets they don’t need and can’t carry. He has owners run three tests on paper: reserve after the purchase, payback on half the expected sales, and fit with the core business. When all three pass, a hard year can be the best time to buy. When any fails, waiting is the smart move.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Investing in a Recession?

Is it smart to invest in a business during a recession?
It can be, if your reserve still covers several months of costs afterward, the purchase pays back even on cautious sales numbers, and it’s close to what your business already does well.
How much cash reserve should I keep before investing?
A common guide is at least six months of operating costs left after the purchase. Your industry and risks may call for more.
What should a business avoid buying in a downturn?
Assets outside your core business, purchases that drain your reserve, and anything that only works if sales stay strong.

Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, business consultant and author of books on Amazon. Tempted by a bargain? Run the three tests with Dr. Paul.

This page is for general education. It is not legal, tax, accounting, or financial advice. Numbers are illustrations unless noted, and the Fabled Forest is invented. For decisions about your own business, talk with a qualified professional.