Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
Business Consultant & Author
Should a Small Business Take Credit Cards and Digital Payments?
The Fee Is Small. The Walkout Is Not.
Owners who refuse cards almost always overestimate the fees and underestimate the walkouts. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, hears the same reasons across 1,000+ clients: the fees are too high, cash is simpler, cards feel risky. Then he asks how many customers left last week because they couldn’t pay the way they wanted. Nobody knows, because nobody counts. Here is how to count.
Last Updated: 11/15/2026 · Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA
The Definition
What Counts as a Digital Payment?
Short Answer
Digital payments cover every non-cash way to pay: cards, tap, phone wallets, and online checkout. Accepting them usually means a monthly charge for the service or reader plus a small cut of each sale. The decision weighs those charges against the profit you lose when people can’t pay the way they prefer.
Take cards if: lost profit from walkouts > monthly fee + (percentage × card sales)
Doctor Owl, in Plain English
“A customer who cannot pay you is still a customer you lost. Count them before you decide the fee is too much.”
How This Guide Works
Need the math? The Short Answer and the four steps walk through it. Want the story? Follow Louie, a labrador from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series who runs a waffle café with a COINS ONLY sign on the register. His story runs in gold notes, and the fee math has its own section.
Not Sure Card Fees Are Worth It for Your Business?
Run the comparison with Dr. Paul, build it into your plan, or learn the method first. Start by counting a week of walkouts.
Business Consulting
FeaturedWeighing card fees against lost sales? Dr. Paul helps you run the real numbers for your business.
See consulting options →Business Plan Writing
Dr. Paul writes plans with payment processing costs built into the margins lenders review.
Start your plan →Business Plan Templates
A Word plan and Excel model with a merchant fee line you can adjust.
Browse templates →Small Business Education
Free lessons and Fabled Forest books on payments, pricing, and cash flow.
Start learning →From Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest
Meet Louie: A Labrador Who Only Takes Coins
Louie runs Waffle Woofs on the square, and in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series, he is the cheerful owner who likes things simple. Cash, he says, is honest. You can see it and make change with it.
The forest bank has started issuing payment cards, and Doctor Owl has just used his first one at the general store. He walks across the square for breakfast with the card in his wing and finds the sign on Louie’s register. He puts the card away and pays in coins. Then he sits at the corner table and watches the counter.
Why It Matters
Why Do Cash-Only Businesses Lose More Than They Think?
Because the loss is invisible. A customer who can’t pay by card rarely complains. They put the item back, say they’ll come back later, and go somewhere that takes their card. The register never records the sale that didn’t happen.
Meanwhile the fee is very visible. It shows up on a statement every month. So owners compare a fee they can see to a loss they can’t, and the fee loses. Digital payments are a math problem, and the math only works when both sides get counted.
Signs you have this problem:
- Customers ask “do you take cards?” more than once a day.
- People leave a full order on the counter and say they’ll find an ATM.
- Younger customers seem to come in less often.
- You turn down large orders because the customer can’t bring cash.
- Staff have learned to point to the nearest bank machine.
- You have never tallied how many customers leave over payment.
In the Fabled Forest
The vole at Louie’s till was quietly making a mark on a card every time a customer walked away over the sign. Nobody had asked her to. Nobody had asked to see the card, either.
The Real Costs
What Does It Cost to Take Card Payments?
- A monthly fee. For the reader, the service, or both. Some plans have none.
- A percentage per sale. Usually a small share of each card transaction, sometimes plus a few cents.
- Setup and equipment. A reader or a phone add-on, often low cost.
- Payout timing. Card money can take a day or two to reach your bank. Plan cash flow around it.
- Your price. Some owners build the fee into prices instead of eating it. Check the rules where you are before adding any surcharge.
In the Fabled Forest
Isabelle the Iguana, a banker at the corner table, worked it out on the back of an envelope. About ten coins in fees every four weeks. Against that, about ninety-six coins of profit from the customers walking out. “Ninety-six,” she said. “Against ten.”
Making the Call
How Do You Decide If Card Fees Are Worth It?
Count first. For one week, have whoever runs the register mark every customer who leaves, or nearly leaves, because of how they wanted to pay. Then price the fees on the sales that would go through cards. Compare the fee to the profit on the lost sales, not the full price of the sales.
If the lost profit is bigger, take both cash and cards. Keep cash for the customers who prefer it. The aim is not to switch. It is to stop turning money away at the door. This is the same kind of weighed choice the total cost of ownership page uses for any tool.
In the Fabled Forest
Louie took both. By the end of the month, the walkout column had a single mark in it: a jay who had wanted to pay in acorns. He pinned the old COINS ONLY sign under the new reader, upside down, so he would remember.
The Numbers
Do Card Fees Cost More Than Lost Sales?
Here is a café’s week, counted both ways. Run the same comparison with your own walkout tally and fee quote.
| Item | Per week | How it’s figured |
|---|---|---|
| Customers who walked out over payment | 20 | Tally kept at the register |
| Average ticket | $9 | From the register |
| Profit per ticket | $5 | Price minus food and supplies |
| Lost profit from walkouts | $100 | 20 × $5 |
| Card sales if accepted | $900 | 100 tickets × $9 |
| Card fees (3% plus $8 monthly, weekly share) | $29 | $27 + about $2 |
| Net gain from taking cards | $71 | $100 − $29 |
Illustration. The book counts walkouts with marks on a card; these dollar figures and fee rates are examples. Get real quotes.
Step 1: Price the walkouts. 20 lost customers × $5 profit = $100 a week in profit that never showed up.
Step 2: Price the fees. 3% of $900 in card sales = $27, plus about $2 of the monthly fee = $29 a week.
Step 3: Compare. $100 lost versus $29 in fees means taking cards is worth about $71 a week, or roughly $3,700 a year, before counting customers who come back.
Illustrative numbers only.
Step by Step
How Do You Decide on Digital Payments Step by Step?
Four steps and one week of honest counting.
Count a week of walkouts.
Tally each customer who walks out, or almost does, over how they wanted to pay.
Get the real costs.
Ask for the monthly fee and the percentage per sale in writing.
Estimate the card volume.
Guess how much would go through cards, then work out the fees on that amount.
Compare and take both if it pays.
Weigh the fees against the profit on lost sales, then accept cards and cash together. The common mistake is comparing the fee to zero instead of to the sales walking out the door.
In the Fabled Forest
A shrew came in for the Monday dozen with only a card. Louie handed her the box. “Pay me Wednesday,” he said. “On the card. The box will be here.”
Louie’s Full Story
How Many Marks Were on the Card?
The book has Doctor Owl’s first card payment, the vole’s quiet tally, the envelope where Isabelle priced the fees, and the day the old sign went up upside down.
Technology and AI for Small Businesses teaches each technology decision through one owner’s story and a Nutshell you can use that week.
A Business Consultant’s View
What Do Business Consultants Hear From Cash-Only Owners?
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA · Business Consultant
Cash-only owners tell Dr. Paul the fees are too high, and they are usually sure of it. Then he asks them to keep a walkout tally for a week. The number almost always surprises them, because lost customers don’t make noise. Dr. Paul also reminds owners to compare the fee with the profit on a lost sale, not its full price, which keeps the math honest in both directions. Most end up taking both cash and cards. It is a small Organize step in his Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy: remove a reason for customers to leave before spending a dollar to attract new ones.
FAQ
What Else Do Owners Ask About Taking Cards?
Is it worth it for a small business to accept credit cards?
How much do credit card fees cost a small business?
Should I go cashless?
Keep Going
Where This Leads
This is foundation 8 of twenty. Every payment term is defined in the technology and AI glossary.
How to Start Selling Online
Take orders and payments from customers far away.
What Is Total Cost of Ownership?
Count every cost of every tool you pay for.
What Are Payment Terms Like Net 30?
How business customers pay later (glossary guide).
How to Get Customers to Pay on Time
Collecting faster on what you’re owed.
Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, business consultant and author of books on Amazon. Weighing cash against cards? Run the numbers with Dr. Paul.
This page is for general education. It is not legal, security, or other professional advice. No real products are named or endorsed, the numbers are illustrations, and the Fabled Forest is invented.