How Do You Compare Business Loans?

Textbook Definition

The cost of financing is the total expense of borrowing, including interest, origination and other fees, and penalties, typically compared across offers using the total repayment amount and an annualized cost measure such as the annual percentage rate.

In Plain English

Add up every payment you will make over the life of the loan, then subtract what you actually receive after fees. That number is what the money costs you. Compare offers on that number first, then check that the payment fits your month.

Why Do Owners Sign Expensive Loans?

Because lenders advertise the parts that sound good: the amount you get and the payment you make. Both sound manageable. The total, the fees, and what happens if you miss a payment sit in the small print. Fast, no-questions money is almost always the most expensive kind, and it shows up exactly when you need it most.

The rules of a loan, how much, how often, how long, and what happens if you are late, are its terms. Read every line, or have someone read it to you. And remember that borrowing can be a bad idea even when the money is cheap, if what you are buying has never been proven.

Signs you have this problem:

  • You know your loan payment but not what you will pay in total.
  • You signed for money the same day it was offered.
  • A fee was taken out before you received the money.
  • You do not know what happens if you miss a payment.
  • Payments come out weekly or daily from your account.
  • You borrowed to fund an idea you have never tested.
A loan is money you rent. The rent can be cheap or ruinous, and the only way to know is to add it all up before you sign.

What It Looks Like When the Terms Are "Flexible"

From the Fabled Forest · Chapter 16

Startup Steve's barbershop finally works. Now he wants to open bike rentals, and a large fin named Shannon from Undertow Capital offered him three hundred coins by tonight. No questions. The terms were "flexible." Steve had read the big number.

Barnaby the bookkeeper read the rest out loud. A twenty-coin fee taken up front, so Steve would receive 280. Fifteen coins every week for forty weeks: six hundred paid back. Miss two Fridays and it was all due at once. The bank's offer, for the same three hundred, cost sixty in total.

Then Steve found the second problem himself. Even the bank's payment would come out of the barbershop for a year, for bikes nobody had ever rented in the forest. He tore up Shannon's paper, decided to rent five bikes in spring as a test, and asked the bank what to bring when he came back.

Steve's story is Chapter 16 of Accounting and Finance for Small Businesses, Book 2 of Dr. Paul's Fabled Forest Business School Series.

How to Compare Business Loans in 5 Steps

Do this with every offer, even the friendly ones. It takes ten minutes and a calculator.

  1. Get every offer in writing.

    Read every line, including the back page and the small type. If something is unclear, ask the lender to explain it in writing, or have someone you trust read it with you.

  2. Write down what you actually receive.

    The loan amount minus any fees taken up front. If you borrow $30,000 and a $2,000 fee comes off the top, you are borrowing $28,000 at the price of $30,000.

  3. Add up every payment over the full term.

    Payment times number of payments. Weekly and daily payments add up faster than they sound.

  4. Subtract to find the total cost.

    Total paid back minus what you received. That is the total cost of the money. Compare offers on this number first. Then ask your lender for the annual percentage rate to compare offers of different lengths.

  5. Check the payment fits your month, and the bad case.

    Can the business make the payment in a slow month without the new thing working yet? What does one late payment cost? What happens after two? If one missed payment can make the whole balance due, think hard.

Dr. Paul's Insight

The question "can I afford the payment?" comes second, not first. Plenty of expensive loans have small payments. And even a cheap loan is a bad idea if it funds something unproven. Test the idea small with your own money first, then borrow to grow what already works, and bring the lender real numbers. The lender who asks a hundred questions is usually the one offering the cheaper money.

Worked Example: Two Offers, Same $30,000 Fast lender: $2,000 fee off the top, so you receive $28,000. Then $1,500 a week for 40 weeks = $60,000 paid back. Cost of the money: $60,000 − $28,000 = $32,000. Bank: no fee, you receive $30,000. Then $3,000 a month for 12 months = $36,000 paid back. Cost of the money: $36,000 − $30,000 = $6,000. Same amount borrowed. The fast money costs more than five times as much. Figures are an illustration to show the math, not a projection for your business.

Sample: A Loan Comparison Sheet

One column per offer. Compare the bottom lines before you look at the payment.

Amount requested: $30,000Purpose: Equipment
LineFast lenderBank
Amount borrowed$30,000$30,000
Fee taken at signing$2,000$0
Amount you actually receive$28,000$30,000
Payment$1,500 weekly$3,000 monthly
Number of payments4012
Total paid back$60,000$36,000
Total cost of the money$32,000$6,000
If a payment is lateFee; two missed = all due at onceLate fee only

Sample for illustration. Ask each lender for the annual percentage rate and the full fee list in writing.

Lend Fast and Let the Small Print Do the Rest?

In the book, a company called Talon and Beak keeps offering owners shortcuts. Every one sounds reasonable. Every one works for a while. Every one costs more than it saves. Here is the one in Chapter 16.

The Shortcut

Lend fast to owners who are desperate, and bury the real cost in fees, weekly payments, and penalty clauses.

Why It Works for a While

Desperate owners sign the same day, and the payment sounds small.

What It Costs

The owner pays for a year or more, often far more than they borrowed, and tells everyone they know who did it to them.

If an offer is fast, easy, and does not want to talk about the total, add up the total yourself. Then walk away and compare.

Video: How to Find the True Cost of a Business Loan

Video Coming Soon

How to Compare Business Loans: The True Cost of Financing

Dr. Paul compares two real-format loan offers line by line on screen.

He Read the Big Number

Chapter 16 · Cost of Financing

Cash Now, Terms Later: A Monkey and a Shark

"Shannon," he said. "Undertow Capital. He says the bank takes weeks and asks a hundred questions, and he can have three hundred coins in my paw by tonight. No questions." He beamed. "He said the terms are flexible. Limber, even."

Barnaby's pencil stopped moving.

"Did you read them?" asked Doctor Owl.

"I read the big number," said Steve. "Three hundred."

What did Shannon's "flexible" terms really cost, and what did Steve do instead? Find out in Chapter 16. Book 2 of Dr. Paul's Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Get the Book on Amazon →

Business Loan Questions

How do I compare two business loan offers?
Write down what you will actually receive after fees, add up every payment over the full term, and subtract. That total cost is the first comparison. Then compare the annual percentage rate for offers of different lengths, check late fees and default terms, and make sure the payment fits a slow month.
What is the total cost of a loan?
The total cost is everything you will pay back over the life of the loan, minus everything you actually received after fees. It includes interest and all fees. It is the clearest single number for comparing loans, because a small payment can hide a very large total.
What fees should I look for in a business loan?
Origination or signing fees taken from the loan amount, application and processing fees, late payment fees, prepayment penalties, and any clause that makes the full balance due after missed payments. Ask the lender for a complete written list of fees and when each one applies.
Why is fast business funding so expensive?
Lenders who fund quickly with few questions take on more risk and often target owners who need money urgently and have fewer options. They make up for it with higher fees, frequent payments, and strict penalties. Speed is the product being sold, and owners pay heavily for it.

Written by Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, business consultant, author, and educator with an MBA focused in finance. Want a second set of eyes on a loan offer before you sign? See fractional CFO services.

This page is for general educational purposes only. It is not legal, financial, tax, accounting, or lending advice. Tax rules change by place and by year. Dollar figures are illustrations. The Fabled Forest and its characters are fictional. For decisions about your own business, consult a qualified professional.